Every link your nonprofit publishes makes a small promise: click here, and you’ll land where this specific thing lives. You can check, in a few minutes, whether your organization actually keeps that promise, or quietly breaks it dozens of times a month without anyone noticing.
This test checks one specific thing: whether a link naming a specific program or opportunity actually leads to a page about that specific thing, or dumps the visitor onto a general page and leaves them to find it themselves. It’s a promise-keeping check, not a design review.
Step 1: Pull Your Last Five Outbound Links
Say your organization runs a fall scholarship program and promotes the application deadline through both a social post and an email newsletter. Pull the links from both. You’re looking for links that named something specific, “apply for our fall scholarship,” not a generic “visit our website” link, since a vague link can’t really break a promise it never made.
Pulling from more than one channel matters here. If the social post and the email both link to the same place, you learn something different than if they link to two different pages, one might keep the promise while the other doesn’t, even though both campaigns were promoting the exact same scholarship.
Step 2: Click Each One and Ask One Question
Click the social post’s link and ask: does this page match what the post promised? If it leads to a general “Programs” page listing a dozen initiatives, with the scholarship mentioned nowhere above the fold, the promise wasn’t kept. The visitor now has to do the work the link was supposed to have already done for them.
Do the same for the email. If the email’s link leads somewhere different, say, a dedicated scholarship page with the deadline and an apply button visible immediately, you’ve just found that one channel is quietly outperforming the other, using the exact same offer. That gap is worth noticing on its own, since it usually means whoever manages that channel built or found a better page, and nobody told the other team it existed.
Step 3: Score Each Link Against Three Outcomes
Score each link as:
- kept the promise (a direct page with a clear next step),
- partially kept (related, but the visitor has to scroll or click again to find it),
- or broken (a homepage or general page with no path to the specific thing at all).
Applied to the scholarship example: a link landing on a “Programs” page that eventually mentions scholarships three paragraphs down is partially kept. A link landing on the homepage, with no mention of scholarships anywhere visible, is broken.
Neither failure looks dramatic in the moment. Both cost the same thing: a visitor who arrived ready to apply and left instead, at the exact point where the least effort should have been required of them.
What a Pattern of Broken Links Usually Means
If both the social post and the email score as partially kept or broken, it’s rarely a mistake by whoever wrote either one. It usually means the dedicated scholarship page never existed in the first place, so there was nowhere accurate to link to, and whoever published each post did the best they could with what was available.
This is worth saying plainly, because the instinct after finding a broken link is often to blame whoever posted it. The actual gap sits one level up, in whether a specific destination existed at all for that link to point to.
Fixing What You Find, in the Right Order
Not every broken link deserves the same urgency. A partially kept link on an evergreen program that isn’t going anywhere can wait a month. A broken link tied to a hard deadline, like the fall scholarship’s application cutoff, can’t. If you find several problems at once, fix the time-sensitive ones first, then work backward through the rest.
Building the missing page doesn’t have to be elaborate either. A single page with the deadline, the eligibility rules, and an apply button does more good than a polished general page that still makes the visitor guess whether scholarships are even mentioned. Ship the plain version now, refine it later once it exists at all.
Running this test across a handful of recent links is a fast way to see how often your organization’s promises actually get kept, and it maps onto the same kind of check maconRAINE’s implementation workbook walks through at a larger scale, auditing every link and page an organization sends people to, not just five at a time. Chapter 2 of Leap The Nonprofit Discoverability Gap covers this same gap between what a link promises and what it delivers, and it’s free to read.
FAQ
Does a URL shortener or redirect affect this test?
No. Follow the link all the way to its final destination and score that page, not the shortened link itself.
What if the destination page exists but the information on it is outdated, an expired deadline or an old schedule?
Score it as broken, or close to it. Outdated information fails the visitor the same way a missing page does, even though something technically loaded.
If the same campaign performs differently across channels, does that mean one channel is broken and the other isn’t?
Not necessarily broken, but it does mean whoever manages that channel is linking to a different page, worth finding out which one and standardizing on the version that keeps the promise.
Does it matter if a broken link only gets a handful of clicks?
Yes, if those few clicks are the exact people who cared enough to click through in the first place. A low-traffic link that fails everyone who uses it is arguably a worse problem than a high-traffic link that partially works.
